elsewhere

Mark Perry: Putting the Client First

Denis Boyles: Clever people and their funny ways

Robert R. Reilly: Cautionary tales for grown-ups

Geoffrey Luck: Big continents are hard to cross

George Scialabba: Not just feline and impractical

Anthony Cordesman: How does Karzai even have Western friends left?

James Bowman: If you thought British hacks were woeful, look west . . .

Burlington Magazine: Public Sculpturitis

James Panero: Online art criticism and its discontents

latest on CR

No carcass deader: The Realist

Don’t Punic!: Demetri Marchessini

The Goat’s grave is noisy: Tim Congdon

Intern all ex-CRD lags now: Crown Passage

Dave gets what we don’t deserve: Education

BOO to You Too: Robert Oulds

But let’s not overfeed Merv: Tim Congdon

Still shining out: Demetri Marchessini

We hate the BBC too: Crown Passage

So Majorly Unkewl: The Realist

Nobelheads: Tim Congdon

Merry Christmas one & all: Demetri Marchessini

Though we’re still in the red: Tim Congdon

All human life is here: Demetri Marchessini

The mad, bad world of the ECB: Tim Congdon

Here come the Big Numbers: Tim Congdon

Magic money buys mushrooms: Tim Congdon

No wonder they have duvets abroad: Tim Congdon

Oh what a lovely crisis: Tim Congdon

Old skool: Demetri Marchessini

The Hairybacks’ loss was our gain: Noel Lackland

Barry O hasn’t lost yet: Tim Congdon

Boxing ourselves into a tight corner: Terrorism

Dave was quick enough to quit White’s: Roger Helmer

It’s been an odd week round here: Architecture

Europe21/11/2011
We’re in the Wrong Club

Europhiles can’t claim the pro-EU case is the trading opportunity
Roger Helmer

Europhiles like Petros Fassoulas love to tell us that 50% of the UK’s trade is done with Europe, and that this is a good reason for EU membership. Of course they’re wrong on both counts. If you take account of re-exports and the Rotterdam effect, our exports to the EU are a bit over 40% of our total exports (so less than 10% of GDP). Let’s be generous and say 45%. Though bear in mind that this trade is not a good reason for EU membership, since there is no reason why quitting the EU should adversely affect our trade. But pro-EU propagandists are also wrong in a much more fundamental sense. The EU is (roughly) 20% of global trade and global GDP. Instead of saying, “we do 50% (or 45%) of our trade with the EU, so that’s good”, we should be asking, “why are we doing only just over half our trade out in the other 80%?”. It’s not that we’re doing brilliantly in Europe. It’s that we’ve let ourselves down in the bit of the world where the growth is. As John Cridland of the CBI has pointed out, ‘we’ve concentrated too much on Europe – we need to get out and build export markets in the rest of the world’. The growth, today and for as far as we can see into the future, is with the BRICS: China, India, Brazil and so on. One of these, India, is in the Commonwealth, as are Singapore and Malaysia (key players in the dynamic ASEAN group in South East Asia). It is scandalous that in recent decades we have ignored the Commonwealth and to our own detriment.

How have we made this mistake? Locked inside an inward-looking, protectionist, over-regulated European Union, we have allied ourselves primarily and preferentially with the world’s slowest growth area, and turned our back on the dynamic markets elsewhere. It gets worse. While the EU is currently only around 20% of global GDP, it’s actually projected to decline steadily until that figure is halved, to 10%, by 2050. The EU is facing a demographic time-bomb with drastic declines in population over time, which itself undermines GDP growth. We’re in a bad situation in the EU, and it’s getting steadily worse. Nick Clegg warns us that we shall be ‘isolated and marginalised’ if we leave the EU. He’s looking at it backwards: we’re isolated and marginalised in the EU. It’s time to get out of this doomed club and rejoin the real world, where the growth potential is. Or as William Hague put it, ‘the EU is a 1970s solution to a 1950s problem’. Let’s give the last word for now on this subject Roger Bootle, who rightly says that ‘in global terms, the EU is most assuredly in the slow lane. If we weren’t in it already, surely this is a club we shouldn’t want to join’. Amen to that.